By Dani Pidgeon, COO, DealersChoice Solutions, an MRAA Education Champion
When sales slow down, most dealers cut their ad budgets first. That’s usually the wrong move.
According to the NMMA, new powerboat retail unit sales fell 8.8% year over year in the 12 months ending February 2026. The NMMA cited high interest rates leading to cautious consumers (NMMA). With fewer buyers around, every lead counts for more. A dealer who knows what a lead is worth can bid with confidence. A dealer who only knows what a click costs can only cut.
Why is Cost Per Click the Wrong Number to Manage?
Cost per click (CPC) is easy to see, so it gets the attention. But a cheap click that never turns into a phone call or test ride inquiry is worth nothing. A seemingly expensive click from a shopper searching for a specific model you have on the lot could be worth thousands.
The more useful question is: how much can I afford to pay for a lead and still make money? Every dealership can work this out with its own numbers:
- Break-even cost per lead = average gross profit per unit × your lead-to-sale close rate
- Target cost per lead = break-even cost per lead × the share of gross profit you’re willing to spend on advertising
Here’s what that looks like for selling new boats in the $100,000 to $400,000 range, assuming a 10% lead-to-sale close rate and a 10% gross margin. This is an illustrative assumption, so plug in your own numbers.
| Retail price | Gross profit | Break-even cost per lead (10% close rate) | Target cost per lead (5% of gross) |
| $100,000 | $10,000 | $1,000 | $50 |
| $200,000 | $20,000 | $2,000 | $100 |
| $400,000 | $40,000 | $4,000 | $200 |
Break-even is a ceiling, not a goal. At that cost, advertising eats the entire gross profit on the sale, leaving nothing for sales commissions or overhead. So you will want to set a target well below it.
This example caps advertising at 5% of gross profit, which puts the target at $50 to $200 per lead, depending on the price of boats you have on your lot. Set your own percentage based on the numbers you are comfortable with.
That changes how a click looks. A $10 click on a model-specific search seems expensive, but if 1 in 10 of those clicks turns into a lead, you’re paying $100 per lead. That’s over target for a $100,000 boat, right on target for a $200,000 boat and well under target for a $400,000 boat.
That’s why targets should be set by product line, not across the whole account. Cutting high-dollar model searches to save money could mean giving up your most profitable shoppers.
Action items for your team or dev partner:
- Pull average gross profit for the last 12 months
- Calculate your lead-to-sale close rate
- Set a break-even and a target cost per lead for each major product line (pontoon, fishing, ski/wake, PWC)
- Share these numbers with whoever manages your ads, so they can bid against them
Are You Counting All the Leads Your Ads Produce?
You can’t value-price a campaign that isn’t tracked properly. For boat dealers, the most common gap is phone calls. Many shoppers see an ad, open your website and call the number in the header. If that call isn’t tracked as coming from the ad, the campaign looks worse than it really is.
It’s important to note, calls and form fills are only part of the picture. Some shoppers see your ads, research on your website, then walk into the showroom without ever calling or filling out a form. There’s no reliable way to connect that visit back to the ad that started it, so walk-in sales your campaigns influenced go uncounted.
That means every number in your ad reports, from cost per lead to return on ad spend, understates what the campaigns actually produce. Track what you can and treat walk-ins as upside you can’t fully measure.
One low-tech step helps: train your sales team to ask every walk-in how they found you and log the answer in your CRM. It won’t be perfect, but it shows whether ads are driving showroom traffic.
Action items for your team or advertising partner:
- Track calls, not just form fills, using call tracking software (such as CallRail)
- List every conversion action in your Google Ads account and confirm each one is a real lead (not a page view or time on site)
- Use Maximize Conversions bidding and count only real leads (calls and forms) as conversions so Google optimizes toward them
- In year-over-year reports, compare like-for-like lead types and note any tracking changes
How Do You Connect Ad Leads to Actual Boat Sales?
This is the step that changes how a dealer thinks about ad spend: matching the leads your ads produce to the boats you actually sell.
Here’s what this looks like in practice. One multi-store boat dealer we work with matched ad-driven calls to sales in their CRM. From July to September 2026 boat sales tied to Google ads campaigns totaled about $830,000 on $46,000 in ad spend, a 17.9x return.
Action items for your team or advertising partner:
- Record the lead source (including the Google click ID, called GCLID) in your CRM for every web and phone lead
- Set a monthly routine to match closed deals to lead records in your CRM
- Report attributed ROAS as a minimum and record what share of total sales you can match
The Bottom Line: Know What Your Advertising is Worth
A slow market doesn’t mean you should spend less on advertising. It means you need to know what your advertising is worth.
When a dealer can say “every dollar we put into Google ads came back as at least $7 in boat sales and that’s a floor,” the conversation shifts from “can we afford ads?” to “where should the next dollar go?” That shift is what keeps showroom traffic steady when the rest of the market is cutting back.
Editor’s Note: You can connect with the DealersChoice Solutions crew at Dealer Week 2026, Dec. 6-9, in Tampa. Stop by booth No. 683, across from the Sales & Marketing Pathway.

About the Author
Dani Pidgeon is the Chief Operating Officer of DealersChoice Solutions, where she brings over a decade of digital marketing expertise to the marine industry to transform dealership websites into 24/7 lead-generation engines. Relying on hard data to maximize a dealer’s return on investment, Dani specializes in SEO, GEO, conversion rate optimization (CRO), content marketing, and high-intent PPC.
When she isn’t helping boat dealers dominate their local search territories, Dani stays close to her outdoor roots by barrel racing with her horses, fishing, or writing farm-focused children’s books.
Editor’s note: MRAA publishes partner-contributed articles to provide marine retailers with practical education, subject-matter expertise and industry perspective. MRAA maintains editorial oversight of partner-contributed content and may edit submissions for clarity, relevance, AP style, search visibility and alignment with MRAA’s dealer-first educational standards. Recommendations should be considered alongside each dealership’s goals, processes, team capacity and business needs.